
The Pontchartrain Hotel
Best for travelers who want a historic Garden District boutique with multiple lively bars and a rooftop craft-cocktail scene.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Pontchartrain Hotel is a circa-1927 boutique hotel in New Orleans' Garden District with lively on-site restaurants, a rooftop bar and an adults-oriented vibe. The Windsor Court is an upscale five-star luxury hotel close to Canal Street and the riverfront, suited to travelers who want polished service, larger facilities and an on-site spa.
Updated · about 3.5 km apart

Best for travelers who want a historic Garden District boutique with multiple lively bars and a rooftop craft-cocktail scene.

Best for travelers who prefer five-star polish, an on-site full-service spa, a larger hotel with meeting space and a riverfront-adjacent location.
When The Pontchartrain Hotel wins: pick The Pontchartrain for a boutique, adults-oriented stay in the Garden District with easy streetcar access, multiple in-house dining venues and a rooftop bar (Hot Tin) geared to evening social life.
When The Windsor Court wins: choose The Windsor Court for full five-star service, larger rooms, an on-site full-service spa, a year-round outdoor pool and extensive meeting/banquet facilities.
Bottom line: The Pontchartrain is the choice for a smaller, characterful Garden District experience and nightlife; The Windsor Court is the choice for classic five-star amenities, space for events and a riverfront-central base for sightseeing.
| Category | The Pontchartrain Hotel | The Windsor Court |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, boutique and adults-oriented; lively bars and rooftop scene | Upscale five-star luxury, polished and formal |
| Location | Garden District on St. Charles Avenue; streetcar stop in front | Near Canal Street and the Mississippi River; steps from downtown/CBD |
| Size (rooms) | 106 rooms and suites | 314 guestrooms |
| Check-in age / audience | Minimum check-in age 21; adults-oriented property | All ages welcome; family-friendly |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool | One outdoor pool (pool cabanas available at surcharge) |
| Restaurants & bars | 4 venues: Jack Rose (dinner/brunch), Bayou Bar (live jazz), Hot Tin (rooftop drinks, 21+), Silver Whistle Café (breakfast) | The Grill Room plus 2 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service; poolside bar |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; daily access to nearby Franco’s Gym included with destination fee | Full-service spa with massage treatments and on-site fitness center |
| Meeting & event space | About 5,000 sq ft total; The Parlor (2,790 sq ft) and other event rooms | 10 meeting rooms and roughly 10,000 sq ft of conference/banquet space |
| Known for | Garden District location, rooftop Hot Tin and live-jazz Bayou Bar | Five-star service, large rooms, spa and conference facilities |
| Parking | Valet parking for a fee; limited street parking nearby | Valet parking (surcharge); electric car charging station also available |
The Pontchartrain sits on St. Charles Avenue in the Garden District with a streetcar stop directly in front.
Pick The Pontchartrain for a quieter, Uptown-adjacent base with direct streetcar access to downtown.
The Windsor Court sits close to Canal Street and the Mississippi River, placing you near downtown attractions and the French Quarter edge.
Pick The Windsor Court for central, riverfront-adjacent access to downtown New Orleans and tourist sites.
The Pontchartrain has 106 rooms and suites that emphasize period character and boutique scale.
Expect smaller, design-forward rooms with historic character and private bars rather than large modern suites or 24-hour room service.
The Windsor Court offers 314 guestrooms with traditionally fitted five-star finishes and larger room options.
Expect a broad range of larger, service-oriented rooms and suites with standard five-star amenities.
The Pontchartrain centers its food and drink on four distinct in-house venues that fuel its social life.
Choose The Pontchartrain for a variety of on-site dining and nightlife options concentrated within one boutique property.
The Windsor Court provides a classic hotel dining experience anchored by The Grill Room plus multiple lounges and 24-hour room service.
Choose The Windsor Court for traditional, full-service hotel dining and late-night room service options.
The Pontchartrain does not have an on-site pool; instead it emphasizes rooftop views and nearby gym access.
If a pool is important, The Pontchartrain is not the right choice; it trades pool amenities for rooftop views and boutique atmosphere.
The Windsor Court includes an outdoor pool and poolside bar as part of its full-service offering.
The Windsor Court is the better pick if you want an on-site pool and a dedicated spa.
The Pontchartrain leans on neighborhood partnerships for wellness and offers a nightlife-focused program on site.
The Pontchartrain is for guests who want local-flavored nightlife and don't need an on-site spa or gym.
The Windsor Court provides on-site wellness and quieter, formal evening options.
The Windsor Court is better if you want on-site spa services and quieter, conventional hotel nightlife.

The Pontchartrain — rooftop Hot Tin and Bayou Bar live-jazz nights give the hotel an active in-house evening scene.

The Windsor Court — full-service spa, on-site fitness center and an outdoor pool fit classic luxury expectations.

The Windsor Court — roughly 10,000 sq ft of conference space and ten meeting rooms suit larger business events.

The Pontchartrain — historic 1927 building, Garden District address and neighborhood dining access emphasize local character.
The Windsor Court — it has an outdoor pool and an on-site full-service spa. The Pontchartrain does not have a pool or on-site spa; it provides gym access off-site.
The Windsor Court is closer to Canal Street, the riverfront and downtown attractions. The Pontchartrain sits in the Garden District with streetcar access to the French Quarter.
The Windsor Court welcomes guests of all ages. The Pontchartrain is adults-oriented and enforces a minimum check-in age of 21 (the rooftop Hot Tin is 21+).
Neither hotel is an all-inclusive property; The Windsor Court offers breakfast for a surcharge, and The Pontchartrain has on-site dining but rates typically do not include meals.
Explore how The Pontchartrain Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·