
The Pontchartrain Hotel
Best for history, a lively on-site food-and-drink program (Jack Rose, Bayou Bar, Hot Tin) and direct St. Charles streetcar access.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Pontchartrain Hotel is a circa-1927, historic Garden District boutique on St. Charles Avenue with multiple on-site restaurants and a 21+ rooftop bar; good for travelers who want period character, easy streetcar access, and an adults-oriented night scene. Hotel Saint Vincent is a fashion-forward luxury boutique on Magazine Street in the Lower Garden District with an outdoor pool and Mediterranean dining; read this if you prefer contemporary design, Magazine Street shopping, and a small-hotel pool.
Updated · about 0.8 km apart

Best for history, a lively on-site food-and-drink program (Jack Rose, Bayou Bar, Hot Tin) and direct St. Charles streetcar access.

Best for stylish, contemporary rooms, a courtyard/outdoor pool and being steps from Magazine Street boutiques and cafes.
When The Pontchartrain Hotel wins: choose The Pontchartrain if you want a historic Garden District address, multiple distinctive in-house dining and bar venues (including a 21+ rooftop with skyline views), preferred access to those venues, and direct streetcar access to the French Quarter and CBD.
When Hotel Saint Vincent wins: pick Hotel Saint Vincent if you prefer a smaller, design-led boutique with an outdoor pool, on-site Mediterranean dining (San Lorenzo), and immediate proximity to Magazine Street shopping and cafes.
Bottom line: both sit outside the French Quarter and work well as boutique alternatives in the Garden District orbit — Pontchartrain is the classic, nightlife-forward historic option; Hotel Saint Vincent is the modern, Magazine Street–adjacent choice with a pool.
| Category | The Pontchartrain Hotel | Hotel Saint Vincent |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, adults-oriented boutique with period character and multiple in-house venues | Fashionable, design-forward luxury boutique |
| Location | St. Charles Avenue, directly on the streetcar line (2031 St. Charles Ave) | Lower Garden District, steps from Magazine Street (1507 Magazine St) |
| Size (rooms) | 106 rooms and suites | 75 rooms |
| Building / age | Circa 1927; renovated (major renovation completed 2016) | Not published |
| Pools | No on-site pool | 1 outdoor pool |
| Restaurants & bars | 4 venues: Jack Rose (dinner/brunch), Bayou Bar (live jazz), Silver Whistle Cafe (breakfast), Hot Tin (rooftop cocktails) | 2 restaurants (includes San Lorenzo Mediterranean), 2 bars/lounges and a coffee shop |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; complimentary access to nearby Franco’s Gym via amenity fee | Spa services on site; complimentary use of a nearby fitness center |
| Known for | Rooftop Hot Tin bar with 270-degree views and an adults-focused atmosphere | Magazine Street location and stylish design; small-hotel leisure pool |
| Check-in age | Reservation holder must be 21 to check in; hotel positioned as adults-oriented | |
| Parking | Valet parking for a fee (in/out privileges); limited free street parking nearby | Free self parking onsite and free RV/bus/truck parking |
The Pontchartrain sits directly on St. Charles Avenue with a streetcar stop in front, placing you in the historic Garden District between uptown and downtown.
Best if you prioritize historic streets, streetcar access, and proximity to both uptown and downtown.
Hotel Saint Vincent is in the Lower Garden District, literally steps from Magazine Street’s shops and restaurants.
Best if you want to be on Magazine Street with quick walking access to local boutiques and cafes.
Pontchartrain’s rooms mix period details with modern updates across several suite types.
Pick Pontchartrain for larger historic suites and an in-room bar rather than traditional room service.
Hotel Saint Vincent offers a range of contemporary room types and suites geared toward design and comfort.
Choose Hotel Saint Vincent for design-forward, amenity-packed rooms and a smaller, more intimate footprint.
The Pontchartrain runs four distinct food-and-drink venues on site, covering breakfast through late-night cocktails.
Pontchartrain suits travelers who want a varied food-and-drink program without leaving the hotel.
Hotel Saint Vincent centers dining around Mediterranean-influenced San Lorenzo and has additional on-site bars and a cafe.
Hotel Saint Vincent is a good pick if you want contemporary dining and a quieter in-hotel restaurant offering.
The Pontchartrain does not have an on-site swimming pool and instead offers neighborhood access and a rooftop bar.
Avoid Pontchartrain if an on-site pool or in-hotel fitness center is a must for your trip.
Hotel Saint Vincent provides an outdoor pool and terrace space for guests.
Hotel Saint Vincent is the better choice when an outdoor pool and outdoor hotel leisure space matter.
Pontchartrain leans into nightlife with live jazz at Bayou Bar and rooftop craft cocktails at Hot Tin.
Pick Pontchartrain if on-site music and late-night cocktails are part of your plan.
Hotel Saint Vincent offers on-site spa services and a quieter, design-focused evening experience.
Choose Hotel Saint Vincent for in-house spa treatments and more subdued evenings near Magazine Street.

Hot Tin rooftop bar with 270-degree views and late-night hours.

Steps from Magazine Street boutiques, cafes and galleries.

Hotel Saint Vincent has an outdoor pool and terrace space for guests.

The Pontchartrain is a restored 1920s hotel with period character and local history.
Hotel Saint Vincent has an outdoor pool; The Pontchartrain does not have an on-site pool.
Hotel Saint Vincent is on Magazine Street; The Pontchartrain is about a 10-minute walk (roughly 0.4 mi) away.
Neither property is strictly adults-only as a whole, but both list a minimum check-in age of 21; The Pontchartrain operates an adults-only rooftop bar (Hot Tin).
Hotel Saint Vincent lists spa services on site; The Pontchartrain does not have an on-site spa or gym but includes access to a nearby gym (Franco’s) via an amenity fee.
Explore how The Pontchartrain Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·