
The Pontchartrain Hotel
Best for intimate historic character, rooftop views, and Garden District atmosphere.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Pontchartrain Hotel is a circa-1927, adults-oriented boutique hotel in the Garden District with a celebrated rooftop bar and four on-site dining venues. The Roosevelt New Orleans, A Waldorf Astoria Hotel is a large, historic grand luxury hotel in the Central Business District for travelers who want big‑hotel amenities and a central downtown base.
Updated · about 3 km apart

Best for intimate historic character, rooftop views, and Garden District atmosphere.

Best for business travel, large events, and travelers wanting full-service luxury amenities (spa, pool, conference space).
When The Pontchartrain Hotel wins: choose the Pontchartrain if you want a smaller, characterful Garden District stay with a strong restaurant/bar scene, an iconic rooftop (Hot Tin), and a streetcar stop outside your door. It’s the pick for couples or adults who prioritize atmosphere over resort-style amenities.
When The Roosevelt wins: choose The Roosevelt if you need large‑hotel services — a full-service spa, outdoor pool, extensive meeting and ballroom space, multiple restaurants/bars, and easy walking access to Canal Street, Bourbon Street and downtown attractions.
Bottom line: Pontchartrain = boutique, neighborhood character and rooftop nights; Roosevelt = grand, full-service downtown luxury with business and event infrastructure. Pick based on whether you want a small, atmospheric hotel or a large landmark with more facilities.
| Category | The Pontchartrain Hotel | The Roosevelt New Orleans, A Waldorf Astoria Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Boutique, historic, adults-oriented | Grand, large-scale historic luxury |
| Location | Garden District on St. Charles Ave (streetcar stop outside) | Central Business District, steps from Canal Street and Bourbon Street |
| Size (rooms) | 106 rooms and suites | 504 guestrooms |
| Age / style | Circa 1927; renovated 2016; boutique character | Historic grand hotel (landmark CBD property) |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Outdoor pool (number of outdoor pools: 1) |
| Restaurants & bars | Four venues: Jack Rose, Bayou Bar, Silver Whistle Café, Hot Tin (rooftop) | Four restaurants, 2 bars/lounges and a coffee shop (on-site dining options) |
| Spa & fitness | No on-site spa or gym; daily access to nearby Franco’s Gym included | Full-service spa and 24-hour fitness facilities on site |
| Known for | Hot Tin rooftop bar with river/downtown views and live-music ground-floor venues | Grand ballrooms, conference space (59,998 sq ft), brand prestige (Waldorf Astoria) |
| Family / age policy | Adults-oriented property; check-in minimum 21 (children possible in some suites) | All ages welcome (family-friendly), check-in min age 18 |
| Distance to French Quarter | About a 20-minute streetcar ride (roughly 15 blocks) | About a 4–10 minute walk to Bourbon Street and the French Quarter edge |
The Pontchartrain sits on St. Charles Avenue in the Garden District with a streetcar stop directly outside.
Pick the Pontchartrain to stay in a residential, historic neighborhood with easy streetcar access.
The Roosevelt sits in the Central Business District steps from Canal Street and Bourbon Street.
Pick The Roosevelt for a central downtown base when you want to be in the middle of the action.
The Pontchartrain has 106 rooms and suites that emphasize period character.
Choose the Pontchartrain for individualized, characterful rooms and a handful of suite layouts.
The Roosevelt offers 504 guestrooms and a broad range of suites and accessibility options.
Choose The Roosevelt when you want many room categories and large-suite options with classic luxury touches.
The Pontchartrain centers its food and drink offering on four distinct, in-house venues with local flavor.
Choose the Pontchartrain for strong, walkable hotel dining and a rooftop‑first drinking scene.
The Roosevelt lists four restaurants, two bars/lounges and an on-site coffee shop across a larger footprint.
Choose The Roosevelt if you want a variety of on-site dining and round-the-clock service options.
The Pontchartrain’s signature amenity is its rooftop bar and views rather than a pool.
Pick the Pontchartrain for rooftop nights and neighborhood atmosphere; don’t book it if you need a hotel pool.
The Roosevelt provides an outdoor pool plus expansive event and meeting spaces as key facilities.
Choose The Roosevelt when you want a hotel with a pool, major event space and full-service facilities.
The Pontchartrain does not have an on-site gym or spa but includes access to a nearby gym.
The Pontchartrain is better for guests who prioritize food, bars and rooftop nightlife over hotel spa facilities.
The Roosevelt has a full-service spa and 24-hour fitness facilities on property.
The Roosevelt suits travelers who want on-site spa and gym services plus downtown nightlife access.

The Pontchartrain — Hot Tin rooftop bar with 270-degree views and late-night hours.

The Roosevelt — nearly 60,000 sq ft of conference space and large ballrooms.

The Pontchartrain — historic 1927 building, boutique scale and neighborhood setting.

The Roosevelt — full-service spa, outdoor pool, multiple restaurants/bars and valet parking.
The Pontchartrain is designed around an adults-oriented experience with a rooftop cocktail bar and intimate dining — it’s the more romantic, small‑hotel choice.
The Roosevelt — it’s in the Central Business District, a short walk to Canal Street and Bourbon Street; the Pontchartrain requires a 15–20 minute streetcar ride.
Book The Roosevelt for an on-site outdoor pool and a full-service spa. The Pontchartrain has no on-site pool or spa; it offers gym access through a nearby partner.
The Pontchartrain welcomes dogs (up to two per room, up to 50 lbs, $75 non-refundable fee per pet). The Roosevelt’s supplier listing shows a pet deposit/fee policy (pet fee and deposit noted) — check directly for details and exemptions for service animals.
Explore how The Pontchartrain Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·