
The Pontchartrain Hotel
Best for travelers who want a historic Garden District stay with a prominent rooftop bar and locally flavored restaurants.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Pontchartrain Hotel is a circa-1927 boutique hotel in the Garden District with a four-venue dining program and a 21+ rooftop bar; read this if you want historic character, streetcar access, and rooftop skyline views. The Westin New Orleans is an upscale, large riverfront hotel on Canal Street aimed at business and leisure travelers; read this if you want a central riverfront base with convention and conference facilities.
Updated

Best for travelers who want a historic Garden District stay with a prominent rooftop bar and locally flavored restaurants.

Best for visitors who need a large, centrally located riverfront hotel with extensive meeting space and recognizable brand amenities.
When The Pontchartrain Hotel wins: choose the Pontchartrain if you prioritize a smaller, characterful hotel in the Garden District, easy St. Charles streetcar access, multiple on-site bars/restaurants (including a 21+ rooftop), and a quieter, neighborhood feel away from the tourist crowds.
When The Westin New Orleans wins: choose the Westin if you want a large, brand-name property on the riverfront/Canal Street corridor with many rooms, extensive conference/meeting facilities, 24-hour business services, and easy walking access to the French Quarter and riverfront attractions.
Bottom line: pick The Pontchartrain for boutique character, rooftop views, and neighborhood location; pick The Westin for central riverfront convenience, meeting space, and a larger-hotel amenity set.
| Category | The Pontchartrain Hotel | The Westin New Orleans |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, adults-oriented boutique with local personality | Upscale, riverfront business and leisure hotel with brand consistency |
| Location | Garden District on St. Charles Avenue; streetcar stop in front | Riverfront/Canal Street, steps from Bourbon Street and riverfront attractions |
| Size (rooms) | 106 rooms and suites | 462 rooms |
| Check-in age / audience | Adults-oriented; check-in minimum 21 (hotel FAQ) | All ages welcome; check-in min age 21 per supplier listing (reservation holder policy may apply) |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Four venues: Jack Rose (dinner/brunch), Bayou Bar (live jazz), Silver Whistle Cafe (breakfast), Hot Tin rooftop (21+ cocktails) | Bistro at the Bend (restaurant/bistro) + 24-hour room service available; on-site bar/lounge |
| Spa / fitness | No on-site gym or spa; daily access to nearby Franco’s Gym included with amenity fee | Fitness: 24-hour fitness facilities listed; spa: Not published |
| Meeting & event space | About 5,000 sq ft total, includes The Parlor (2,790 sq ft) and other meeting rooms | Large conference center: 25,918 sq ft (13 meeting rooms, ballroom/banquet facilities) |
| Known for | Garden District history, Hot Tin rooftop views, live jazz at Bayou Bar | Canal Street riverfront location, convention/meeting capacity, brand reliability |
| Accessibility & business services | 24-hour front desk, valet parking, limited on-site business amenities; smaller property scale | 24-hour business center, express check-in/out, concierge, extensive meeting support |
The Pontchartrain sits on St. Charles Avenue in the Garden District with a streetcar stop directly in front.
Choose The Pontchartrain if you want a neighborhood stay with streetcar access and Garden District atmosphere.
The Westin New Orleans is on Canal Street at the riverfront, within easy walking distance of Bourbon Street and riverfront sites.
Choose The Westin for straightforward access to the French Quarter, riverfront, and convention areas.
The Pontchartrain is a smaller hotel with about 106 rooms and multiple suite configurations.
Expect characterful, individually scaled rooms and a handful of larger suites — good for couples or small groups.
The Westin has a large inventory of 462 air-conditioned rooms in many configurations and river- or city-view options.
Choose the Westin if you want a wide range of room types and river-view options at a large hotel.
The Pontchartrain offers four distinct on-site venues spanning breakfast, dinner, casual bar food, and a rooftop cocktail bar.
The Pontchartrain is better if you want multiple locally run venues and a rooftop cocktail experience.
The Westin centers dining around Bistro at the Bend plus room service and a hotel bar/lounge.
The Westin works well when you prefer in-house, reliable restaurant and room service options tied to a large hotel.
The Pontchartrain’s signature amenity is its rooftop bar and preferred local perks rather than resort-style facilities.
The Pontchartrain’s rooftop and local-venue perks are the main on-site draw — not pools or a spa.
The Westin emphasizes business and meeting amenities alongside riverfront access.
Pick the Westin if meeting space, business services, and riverfront location are priorities.
The Pontchartrain relies on nearby partners for fitness and focuses on evening live-music venues.
Good for travelers who plan evenings around hotel bars and local music and who don’t need an on-site gym or spa.
The Westin provides on-site fitness and services that fit business travelers and conference-goers.
The Westin is better when you need on-site fitness and business services with easy access to the French Quarter nightlife.

The Pontchartrain Hotel — choose it for historic rooms, neighborhood location, and Hot Tin rooftop views.

The Westin New Orleans — large meeting facilities (25,918 sq ft), 13 meeting rooms, and ballroom/banquet support.

The Pontchartrain Hotel — Hot Tin rooftop (21+ drinks-only) and Bayou Bar’s live-jazz program.

The Westin New Orleans — Canal Street/riverfront address puts major downtown attractions within easy walking distance.
The Westin New Orleans is on Canal Street at the riverfront and is closer on foot to the French Quarter and riverfront sites; The Pontchartrain is in the Garden District with streetcar access into the Quarter.
The Pontchartrain Hotel does not have a pool or on-site spa. The Westin’s supplier listing does not publish a spa or pool detail here.
The Westin New Orleans — it has extensive meeting space (about 25,918 sq ft) and a 24-hour business center; The Pontchartrain offers smaller event spaces like The Parlor and fewer total meeting square feet.
Both accept guests of all ages, but The Pontchartrain is described and operated as an adults-oriented boutique property (check-in minimum 21 and a 21+ rooftop). The Westin is positioned for all ages and convention/leisure travelers.
Explore how The Pontchartrain Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·