
The Pontchartrain Hotel
Best for travelers who prioritize a historic Garden District setting, multiple distinctive on-site bars/restaurants, and an adults-focused rooftop experience.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Pontchartrain Hotel is a circa-1927, adults-oriented boutique hotel in the Garden District with a notable rooftop bar and multiple on-site restaurants; read this if you want a historic, bar-and-dining–forward stay off the tourist track. The Eliza Jane, Autograph Collection is a Marriott-affiliated boutique hotel steps from Canal Street and the French Quarter; read this if you want a centrally located, large boutique with brand backing and straightforward business amenities.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for travelers who prioritize a historic Garden District setting, multiple distinctive on-site bars/restaurants, and an adults-focused rooftop experience.

Best for travelers who want a centrally located hotel near Canal Street/Bourbon Street with larger meeting space and predictable brand-standard amenities.
When The Pontchartrain Hotel wins: pick The Pontchartrain if you want period character, on-site destination restaurants and bars (including Hot Tin rooftop) and an adults-oriented, intimate boutique vibe in the Garden District.
When The Eliza Jane, Autograph Collection wins: choose The Eliza Jane if you need closer walking access to the French Quarter and CBD, more meeting/banquet space, and the consistency or benefits that come with an Autograph/Marriott affiliation.
Bottom line: both are boutique choices with character, but they serve different needs—Pontchartrain for historic Garden District dining-and-nightlife focus; Eliza Jane for central convenience, larger room count and event capacity.
| Category | The Pontchartrain Hotel | The Eliza Jane, Autograph Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, adults-oriented boutique with lively on-site bars | Boutique hotel with Marriott/Autograph backing and business-friendly services |
| Location | Garden District on St. Charles Avenue; streetcar stop outside | Central Business District/edge of French Quarter on Magazine St near Canal St |
| Size (rooms) | 106 rooms and suites | 196 guestrooms |
| Check-in age / audience | Adults-oriented; 21+ to check in | All ages welcome (property notes children 17 and under stay free with adults) |
| Pool | No on-site pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Four distinct venues: Jack Rose, Bayou Bar, Silver Whistle Café, Hot Tin (rooftop) | At least one bar/lounge and on-site breakfast; full-service dining available nearby |
| Spa / fitness | No on-site spa; partner gym (Franco's) access included with amenity fee | Not published |
| Known for | Hot Tin rooftop views, live jazz at Bayou Bar, historic hotel character | Proximity to Canal Street/Bourbon Street and conference/meeting space |
| Meeting & event space | About 5,000 sq ft total (The Parlor, Grande Court and other rooms) with venues for weddings and buyouts | 1729 sq ft of meeting space across 2 meeting rooms (conference/banquet capacity) |
| Pet policy | Dogs only, up to 2 per room; $75 non-refundable fee per pet | Pet-friendly options require direct contact with property; pet fee published as USD 150 per pet per stay |
The Pontchartrain sits on St. Charles Avenue in the Garden District with a streetcar stop directly outside.
Choose The Pontchartrain for a Garden District base with easy streetcar access to downtown.
The Eliza Jane is on Magazine Street near Canal Street, placing it within a short walk of the French Quarter and CBD.
Choose The Eliza Jane for immediate access to the French Quarter, Canal Street, and downtown business districts.
Pontchartrain's 106 rooms and suites blend historic architecture with modern refreshes.
Expect smaller scale and distinctive suite options at The Pontchartrain.
Eliza Jane offers 196 guestrooms across a larger property footprint and a broad set of room types.
Choose Eliza Jane for a wider choice of room types and more standard hotel-room amenities.
The Pontchartrain provides four distinct on-site dining/drink venues spanning breakfast to late-night rooftop cocktails.
Pontchartrain is focused on on-site culinary and cocktail experiences as part of the stay.
Eliza Jane includes at least one bar/lounge and offers breakfast; additional dining options are nearby on Canal and in the French Quarter.
Eliza Jane is convenient for downtown dining and quick access to French Quarter restaurants.
Pontchartrain centers its signature amenity on Hot Tin, a rooftop craft-cocktail bar with wide views rather than a pool.
Pontchartrain's signature draw is its rooftop bar and historic-dining scene, not poolside leisure.
Eliza Jane's supplier listing emphasizes central location and event space rather than a rooftop or pool feature.
Eliza Jane is more oriented to downtown events and business travelers than to rooftop or resort-style amenities.
Pontchartrain offers partner-gym access included with the daily amenity fee and a nightlife focus on hotel bars.
Pontchartrain mixes off-site fitness access with hotel-driven nightlife venues.
Eliza Jane lists a 24-hour fitness facility and a bar/lounge for evening plans.
Eliza Jane provides round-the-clock fitness and downtown nightlife access; spa services are not published.

The Pontchartrain Hotel — Hot Tin offers rooftop craft cocktails and 270° views of downtown and the Mississippi River.

The Eliza Jane — a short walk to Canal Street and Bourbon Street puts the French Quarter within easy reach.

The Eliza Jane — lists 1729 sq ft of conference space and two meeting rooms for events and business groups.

The Pontchartrain Hotel — a circa-1927 building with period details and a compact, intimate footprint.
The Eliza Jane is closer to Canal Street and Bourbon Street; it's about a 5–10 minute walk to Canal Street and under a mile to Bourbon Street.
The Pontchartrain Hotel has Hot Tin, a rooftop craft-cocktail bar that is 21+ and drinks-only. Eliza Jane does not list a rooftop bar in its supplier facts.
The Pontchartrain does not have an on-site pool or spa. The Eliza Jane's supplier listing does not publish on-site pool or spa details.
The Eliza Jane lists 1729 sq ft of conference space and two meeting rooms; The Pontchartrain has larger total event space across multiple rooms (about 5,000 sq ft) and distinctive venues for weddings and buyouts—pick based on the style and size you need.
Explore how The Pontchartrain Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·